HomePersonalKilling Isaac: When God Requires the Hardest Sacrifice

Killing Isaac: When God Requires the Hardest Sacrifice

- Advertisment - LDS Bookstore Jewelry

The gospel of Jesus Christ is one of optimism and hope. We hold onto the good news of the gospel—and rightly so. After all, “men are, that they might have joy” (2 Nephi 2:25). However, we can sometimes avoid and even belittle the hard truths of progression in our determination to find this joy.

It’s rarely intentional. Our only goal is to inspire and motivate. Yet we often believe, whether we realize it or not, that if we just work hard enough, our trials will end the way we want them to. Have you ever heard a phrase similar to this one?

“If you just pray more/harder/better (insert action here), then God will answer you (insert blessing here).”

When our situation worsens or heaven remains silent, we then feel like we’ve failed. If only we could be better, then our lives would be better.

While there is definitely power and blessings that come from living a righteous life, all of God’s children need to be prepared to submit fully to His proving. Seeking to understand and accept suffering and sacrifice is an essential beat of the disciple’s heart.

Consider this quote from Joseph Smith:

“You will have all kinds of trials to pass through. And it is quite as necessary for you to be tried as it was for Abraham and other men of God. . . . God will feel after you, and he will take hold of you and wrench your very heart strings, and if you cannot stand it you will not be fit for an inheritance in the Celestial Kingdom of God.”

God’s request that Abraham kill his only son is one of the most prominent scriptural examples of sacrifice. After waiting for many agonizing years to have a child, Abraham’s willingness to bind Isaac upon the altar and raise his knife is as heart-wrenching as it is admirable.

ChurchofJesusChrist.org

Yet I’ve often found it interesting that Abraham was not required to complete his sacrifice. An angel of the Lord appeared and stopped him from killing Isaac.

So, what do you do when the angel doesn’t appear in your life? What if God actually asks you to “kill” your symbolic Isaac?

For many of us, we experience shock and say in disbelief, “He really had me do it.” In the aftermath, loneliness and ostracism can creep in as we hear testimony after testimony, lesson after lesson promising deliverance and escape if we just do…so very many things.

It’s time for a shift in our thinking as we reexamine what happens when God asks for the hardest sacrifice. Here are three principles important to internalize on this journey.

1. It Can’t Be About the Outcome

Why do we do the things we do? This is one of the most important questions at the heart of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Do we obey out of fear?

Perhaps we expect something in return for our good works. Or we may simply be trying to do our best because it’s all we know how to do.

The answer to why we do the things we do in the gospel evolves and changes over time, but I believe our deepest motivation for serving God should be love. When we love God and want to do His will as an expression of that love, we find the courage to face disappointing or even tragic outcomes.

If our faith is built on wanting our lives to go a certain way, it will likely crumble. If our foundation is built upon a loving relationship with Jesus Christ, it can withstand the necessary trying of our souls.

2. Embrace Opportunities to Know Christ

“Christ in Gethsemane,” by Dan Burr. | ChurchofJesusChrist.org

The greatest example of sacrifice is the ultimate atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ. His suffering is beyond comprehension.

Christ asked if the bitter cup could be passed from Him, just as we often do. Yet He submitted His will and offers us eternal life.

When we are asked to drink from the bitter cup, we can find strength in our progression to become more like Christ. By truly sacrificing, we come a little closer to understanding who He is and how we can follow in His footsteps.

Thus, an agonizing sacrifice should not be seen as a punishment, a consequence, or a failure. Rather, it is an opportunity to know Christ.

3. Trust That God Has Something Better in Store

Artwork by Annie Henrie Nader. | ChurchofJesusChrist.org

This powerful statement from Elder Enzio F. Busche can help us find hope in our darkest times:

“When you are compelled to give up something or when things that are dear to you are withdrawn from you, know that this is your lesson to be learned right now. But know also that, as you are learning this lesson, God wants to give you something better.”

We should never try to lessen the magnitude of a sacrifice, but as we strive to maintain perspective, we can see beyond the pain of this moment. Not much can bring comfort, especially when the “something better” we hope to gain does not come in this life.

Even so, there is strength and courage to be found as we move forward through the mire, hoping to reach a brighter day. As we yield our hopes, dreams, and desires to God, we can rest in the peace, joy, and abundance that only He can provide.

This article was originally published on January 22, 2019, and has been updated.

Stay Connected to What Matters Most


How often do you want to receive emails?



2 COMMENTS

Subscribe
Notify of
2 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Emmy Lou
6 months ago

Thank you, I needed this reminder.

Ralph
6 months ago

Great article… I appreciate the perspectives and how this symbolically translates to our personal lives, trials and challenges to remain obedient regardless of the outcome.

- Advertisment - Shop LDS Gifts
Aleah Ingram
Aleah Ingram
Aleah is a graduate of Southern Virginia University, where she studied English, Creative Writing, and Dance. She now works full time as a marketing and product manager, writer, and editor. She currently hosts the podcast "Single to the Glory" about singlehood in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Aleah served a mission in California and loves baking, Lang Leav poetry, Gaynor Minden pointe shoes, and Bollywood movies.

You Might Enjoy

Tongan Latter-day Saint Missionary Dies While Serving in Ghana

Tributes shared across two countries are honoring Elder Peiholani Kaumāvae Vave, a young Tongan who died while serving a mission for The...

No, Seriously, We Don’t Have Time for Family Scripture Study

As someone who strives to follow Jesus Christ through the words of His apostles, I often hear the prophetic counsel to prioritize...

How to Show Your Gratitude to God | 5 September 2026

Here’s your daily dose of what matters most! When we recognize God’s blessings, our gratitude grows deeper as we thank Him with our...

How to Watch or Listen to October 2026 General Conference Live

The 196th Semiannual General Conference of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints will take place Saturday, October 3, and Sunday,...
Related

The Brass Serpent and Our Modern-Day Unbelief

It is a story referenced in both the Bible and the Book of Mormon. It is a story that can sound pretty scary, especially...

5 Latter-day Saint Quotes About Sacrifice

The principle of sacrifice sits at the center of the gospel of Jesus Christ and has shaped worship across dispensations. From Adam to the...

Overcome the World and Find Rest | 16 April 2026

Here’s your daily dose of what matters most! When stress builds, it's tempting to fill every moment with noise—scrolling, working longer, or replaying the...
- Advertisment - LDS Bookstore Color Scriptures
Recent

Come, Follow Me Study Guide | September 7-13

  “He Shall Direct Thy Paths” Come, Follow Me Study Guide | September 7-13 Reading: Proverbs 1–4; 15–16; 22; 31; Ecclesiastes 1–3; 11–12 Life does not always unfold according to simple formulas, but...

Come, Follow Me Study Guide | August 31–September 6

  “Let Every Thing That Hath Breath Praise the Lord” Come, Follow Me Study Guide | August 31–September 6 Reading: Psalms 102–103; 110; 116–119; 127–128; 135–139; 146–150 A single Hebrew word, Tehillim, frames...