BYU Quarterback Jake Retzlaff Named in Sexual Assault Lawsuit

Jake Retzlaff, the starting quarterback for Brigham Young University’s football team, is facing serious allegations stemming from a civil lawsuit filed in Utah’s Third District Court. The suit, filed by an anonymous woman, accuses Retzlaff of raping and assaulting her at his home in Provo in 2023.

According to the court filing, the woman alleges that Retzlaff forced her to have sex against her will. She stated that she underwent a forensic medical exam, commonly referred to as a rape kit, at a hospital several days later. Initially, she declined to identify her alleged attacker, citing feelings of intimidation.

The lawsuit further claims that the woman later provided Retzlaff’s name to law enforcement after learning that another woman had reported a similar incident involving a football player. During that process, she alleges that a police officer told her that sexual assault victims “never get justice,” a statement the Provo Police Department has firmly denied.

The plaintiff is seeking punitive damages in the case.

In response, an attorney representing Retzlaff released a brief statement declaring his client’s “factual innocence” and expressing confidence in clearing his name. “We look forward to proving that innocence,” the statement read.

BYU also issued a statement acknowledging the lawsuit. “BYU became aware today that a civil lawsuit involving Jake Retzlaff had been filed this morning,” the university said. “The university takes any allegation very seriously, following all processes and guidelines mandated by Title IX. Due to federal and university privacy laws and practices for students, the university will not be able to provide additional comment.”

The Provo Police Department confirmed that it received a report on November 27, 2023, from a woman with the initials A.G. describing a similar incident. According to the department, she was treated respectfully and offered multiple chances to identify her assailant, which she declined. The case was subsequently closed.

In response to the lawsuit’s claim that a police officer discouraged the woman by saying justice would not be served, the department strongly refuted the allegation. “That is not true,” the statement read. “We have a team of dedicated investigators and victim advocates whose sole mission is to provide justice to victims of sexual abuse. They do not send people away, warning them there is no justice for victims.”

The department added that its Special Victims Unit regularly secures criminal accountability and that they remain willing to assist the plaintiff if she chooses to participate in further criminal proceedings.

As of now, no criminal charges have been filed in the case.

Who Is Jake Retzlaff?

Jake Retzlaff quickly became one of the most popular athletes at BYU—not just for his talent as a quarterback, but for his energy, confidence, and willingness to embrace the university’s culture. As the first Jewish starting quarterback in school history, he stood out and leaned into that role, creating a space for one of the most underrepresented demographics at the school.

Fans responded with enthusiasm. His bold personality and visible leadership on the field made him a favorite among students, and his unique position led to a nickname that spread across campus and social media: “BYUJew.” The moniker reflected both his heritage and the strong support he received from the BYU community.

Retzlaff’s growing profile was fueled by media appearances, an NIL deal with a kosher food brand, and his role in leading the team through a successful season. He came to represent more than athletic success—many saw him as a symbol of individuality and determination within the BYU football program.

The civil lawsuit against Retzlaff comes at a time when college athletics—both in Utah and nationally—continue to grapple with how institutions respond to sexual assault allegations involving high-profile athletes. Similar accusations have been made in recent years against football players at other Utah schools, prompting difficult conversations about accountability, victim advocacy, and school culture.

These cases highlight the need for careful, thorough investigations that honor the seriousness of such claims while also upholding the legal principle of presuming innocence. As the civil case unfolds, many will likely be watching closely—not just because of who Retzlaff is, but because of what the outcome may signal about how universities and communities handle these deeply sensitive matters.

Holly Wallace

Holly Wallace is a writer and storyteller drawn to meaningful questions and overlooked details. Her work explores Latter-day Saint life and culture through faithful inquiry, inviting readers to pause, consider, and engage more deeply with what matters most.